BRETT FAVRE
Please do your homework.
Favre chose Fox and Greta Van Susteren because Greta is a good friend of Brett’s wife.
On a side note, is PCH a private or public hospital company?
Jay
Let’s make sure I have this right.
You’re telling me to do my homework but you’re asking me if PCH is a private or public hospital five minutes after you posted on our website that it was a private hospital. You reported something you didn’t know and now you rip me for not knowing a FOX news anchor’s circle of friends.
I knew Greta was a Packer’s fan but, I must admit, I do not keep tabs on QB’s wives’ friendships.
Doug,
I understand that you’re entitled to your opinion on your radio show, but I feel that it’s a little irresponsible for you to rant about the Packers brass like you have been lately concerning the Favre situation. If the leader of your team’s heart just isn’t into the game fully, you need to turn the reigns over to the next best option.
You keep saying that Thompson and McCarthy are “stupid”, but who exactly built the best young team in the NFL? You can’t question is the team going 13-3 along with being the youngest team in the NFL. As for McCarthy, he brought discipline back to that team that was lacking in the previous years. He held Favre accountable for his play and look at what happened over the last two years?
The 49ers had Joe Montana and they had to make a tough choice as well. They had a somewhat unproven, but talented player named Steve Young who was ready to step up and be the man while Joe was starting a downward spiral toward retirement. They traded Montana away and let the kid play.
Maybe Aaron Rodgers isn’t the best chance for the Pack to win right now but neither was Ben Roethlisberger for the Steelers, or Tom Brady with the Patriots. Maybe we should give the guys making these decisions the benefit of the doubt before crucifying them on a public forum with no relevant information to back it up.
Billy
It’s never irresponsible for me to rant about anything. I’m irresponsible if I cheat on my wife or raise my children without discipline. My job is to give my opinion. I think the Packers brass are idiots for the way they are handling the Brett Favre situation.
I don’t care how hard it was on them to go through the draft and mini-camp without Favre. It doesn’t matter where Favre’s heart was from March-June. What matters is where it is right now. When one of the top 5 QB’s on the planet wants to play for your franchise and you don’t have one of the other four, the intelligent answer is, “yes.” Anything else is stupid.
Your Joe Montana reference is worthless. They didn’t “let the kid play.” Montana missed part of one year with a concussion and a back issue and all of the next with an elbow injury. Young had already taken the starting spot from him. Roethlisberger and Brady are the same way. After an injury to the starting QB, they played better than the starting QB did.
My relevant information is 61,655 yards with a 61% completion percentage with 442 TD’s with the a streak as incredible as Cal Ripken’s compared to 329 yards on 59% passing and the same number of TD’s as INT’s. But you’re right; maybe we should give these guys the benefit of the doubt when it comes to leaving Bill Buckner in the game when you’ve got a defensive replacement. It’s wrong for me to criticize Marty Morningweg for choosing to go on defense first in overtime because I’ve never been a head coach in the NFL.
Guys, I don’t think the great people of Wisconsin are siding with the Organization on this one. I think the season is nearing and they were all prepared to back Johnny Newkid. There is no doubt everyone wishes it worked out differently, but it hasn’t. It’s starting to make me sick to my stomach. Either way, the Pack goes 10-6, or better this season.
James
You must realize how much I appreciate you listening before you read my next sentence.
You’re crazy.
Winning 10 games is hard. Winning 10 games after you tell a Hall of Famer to go away, impossible.
Guys - LOVE the show.
Brett Favre has been a great QB. But there is a downside. Fans are tired of the on-again, off-again retirement issue. Fans want to win but many believe Brett can’t win the big game. The past 5-6 times the Pack made the playoffs, Brett threw a late game interception that cost GB the game.
The Pack needs to look at Aaron Rodgers for a full season. He is a free agent after this season. Come February of 2009, they are either going to have to offer him a 5 year, multi-million dollar contract - or - let him go. If Brett came back, no doubt, he’d retire for real after this season. Then the Pack would have no sure choice for QB. Even if they go 8-8 this year, they are better off building for the future. It is time to move on.
Joe
Although I disagree on who should be the Packs’ QB next year, this is the best e-mail I’ve received on the subject.
Thanks for listening.
Maybe this retirement was an emotional decision, but how many free passes do we give the guy? He does this every year! Do you think that the Pack would draft the way they did if they knew he was coming back? Do you think they’d work free agency the way they did? At what point do we say that Brett Favre is making himself bigger than the team, and why is that acceptable?
Paul
What Brett is doing is a joke. What the Packers are doing is idiotic.
Every QB who’s fixed as the starter is bigger than the team.
Can we institute a rule in sports that once a player decides to retire, he cannot undo it. I cannot stand the Brett Favre chat. When a person undoes his retirement and then retires multiple times it hurts the franchise. I agree with Green Bay to hold him to his word because after listening to his retirement speeches, he is not much of a man. He cannot decide what to do with his future.
Michael
No we can’t. I think we’re Americans so we can do what we want and I don’t want to trample on Brett’s freedom.
Recent Comments