Archive for March 4th, 2009

Burns: Warner is a Cardinal … Duh!

Kurt Warner is a Cardinal.  Well … duh.

In the history of duh’s this has to be in the top ten.

Were you actually worried about Kurt Warner signing elsewhere?

Did you allow those who peddle panic and deal in fear convince you that there was actually a chance that Kurt Warner was going to leave the Cardinals and the Cardinals were going to allow him to go?

The ultimate irony of this story is that it happened exactly the same day that Manny Ramirez signed with the Dodgers.  I’ve said for a week now, that their two situations were almost exactly identical.  Neither player had any other reasonable option; neither team could run the risk of infuriating their fan base.  I guess irony can be pretty ironic sometimes (the best line from one of the worst movies of all time, Airplane 2).

The truth is he was never, ever, ever (ever to the nth degree) going anywhere.  And everybody knew it.   Once you removed emotion from the equation and just concentrated on common sense…there was no choice.  He had to come back and they had to have him back.

The big winner in this process is Warner, but even more so, his agent Mark Bartelstein.  Some agents (see Drew Rosenhaus) negotiate like nuclear bombs.  They come in with Uzi’s in both hands and just start firing away.

Bartelstein was like a roof top sniper.  Quiet but just as deadly.  And he used the perception of the Cardinals against them, just like I had thought he would.

Warner’s counter offer was for less than what he wanted, less than what the 49ers had offered, and even included money he would give back to Anquan Boldin.  By doing that, the national talking heads on ESPN all universally proclaimed the Cardinals would be fools – even worse than that – they’d be the  Same-Old-Cardinals if they didn’t  accept this deal.

Slaves to their own reputation, the Cardinals had no choice and finished the deal late last night.

Focus now turns to Matt Leinart.  Seems unlikely he’ll just sit around and be a backup for another year.  Brian St. Pierre is telling his hometown newspaper he’s going to have a chance to compete with Leinart for the number two spot.  Between that and the Warner extension, it’s not exactly happy birthday for People magazines favorite benchwarmer.

And of course, Boldin.  Will Warner’s plea force the Cardinals to alter whatever their plan is with Q?

Wish I was as sure about that one as I was about Warner.

Lakin: Yes, but …

Yes, but…

On the surface, signing Kurt Warner to this deal was a no-brainer; best quarterback on the 08-9’ roster, best quarterback on the market, and he gives you the best chance for immediate success.  But let’s look beyond the immediate, as well as into the past.  Rich Gannon, the most recent and most analogous quarterback to Warner, lasted only three games into his age 38 season, one that has also cut short the careers of Steve Young, and for all intents and purposes, Dan Marino.  All three also left without a young successor in place, a title that Matt Leinart might’ve willingly worn two years ago and likely will not two years later.  So, the shoe that hasn’t dropped, likely will sometime before draft day, with Leinart leaving town for a 2nd-round and/or conditional draft pick.  A week ago Kansas City might’ve been a buyer, but their 34th overall choice is headed to New England with Matt Cassel headed the other way.  The other team in the AFC East looking for quarterback would be the New York Jets, having just lost Brett Favre to another one of his retirement fits.  The San Francisco 49ers might be the best fit, but do they really want another underachieving 1st round quarterback on the roster?

As for the Cardinals, their quarterback roster just got better and worse, depending on your outlook.  In the interim, they have a proven winner on a team that finally banks on the prospect of it.  In the future, the outlook at QB is uncertain at best and bleak at worst.  In short, enjoy this while you can…